The Pantry Stuffer

(7 reviews) Write a Review
$15.95 (Fixed Shipping Cost)
Local Courier/Handling is available at check-out. Only $10.95 and replaces fixed shipping. Please select at check-out:
Local Handling delivers to zip codes starting with 410,450,451,452
  • Cutting Board
  • Cincinnati Playing Cards
  • Fiona Fiona Necklace
  • Pewter Ornaments, Set of 4

Stock the pantry with this selection of Cincinnati flavors.  No former Cincinnatian should miss out on this pantry stuffer.  Includes four cans of famous Skyline Chili, Montgomery Inn BBQ Sauce, LaRosa's Pizza Sauce and Italian Dressing, Frisch's Tartar Sauce and Izzy's Famous Dusseldorf Mustard.  All the favorite's can be found in the Pantry Stuffer.

7 Reviews Hide Reviews Show Reviews

  • 5
    The Pantry Stuffer

    Posted by RODMAN KERNEN on Feb 13th 2021

    Great selection and products ! Always First Class Service and Great Folks ! Family and Friends always pleased with gifts !

  • 5

    Posted by Amy C. on Jan 9th 2021

    We sent this to my mother in law in South Carolina! She misses all her Cincinnati favorites! This was the perfect mix of all her favorites! It was much more convenient than purchasing each item and shipping ourselves! Great prices & AMAZING customer service! Super fast shipping! She was BEYOND excited to receive it! We will definitely be ordering again! Highly recommend!

  • 5
    Great products and delivery

    Posted by Marcia Hendershot on Dec 21st 2020

    Was surprised how quickly the order was processed and shipped out of town! Recipients very pleased with the gift!

  • 5
    Has a little bit of everything from Cincy

    Posted by Delana Fuehner on Dec 21st 2020

    This was for friends originally from Cincy and were pleasantly surprised to receive it.

  • 5
    The Best of Cincinnati is the BEST!

    Posted by James Glaser on Nov 19th 2020

    A born and raised Cincinnatian, when life moved me to Maine my heart longed for my favorites of Cincy. The Best of Cincinnati is reasonably priced, best in class customer service and I get my order in record time. The Pantry Stuffer is the perfect blend. Now I just need to get on an auto replenish program. Thank you Best in Cincinnati. You're the best!!

Since 1990 The Best of Cincinnati, Inc. has offered a simple alternative, by presenting to you an exclusive assortment of the finest quality products produced by businesses in Cincinnati. The collection features Cincinnati delicacies that have been selected to exemplify the culinary traditions which have made Cincinnati famous.

Our humble beginnings

Our company was founded as collaboration between a University of Cincinnati student Edward J. Imm and his professor Dr. Ronald J. Dornoff. The concept came to be as many local restaurants entered the grocery store market by bottling or canning such famous Cincinnati products such as Montgomery Inn BBQ Sauce, Skyline Chili, and Gold Star Chili. Mr. Imm presented a business plan as a class project to bring local products together in gift baskets and boom the company was off and running.

Over the years the company has had many expansions into new products and new markets. As Cincinnati has added new restaurants and new venues so has The Best of Cincinnati, Inc. Interestingly, Mr. Imm vowed as a student to someday enter the world of education to “pay back” what he had learned in his many years in business assuming all went well. After 28 years of the good, the bad, and the ugly of the business world Mr. Imm is an adjunct business instructor at The University of Cincinnati in the Carl H. Lindner College of Business.

Our Products

You will find our collection of gifts perfect for friend, family, customers, visitors and valued clients, and you will take pride in giving the quality and distinctiveness of Cincinnati’s unique products. Graeter’s fine Chocolates, Montgomery Inn BBQ Sauce, Skyline Chili is just a few of the more popular products we put in our beautiful gift baskets. Additionally, we carry items from Izzy’s Famous Delicatessen, LaRosa’s Pizzeria, Busken Bakery, and Queen City Coffee. Our gift baskets can be delivered locally or shipped out of town. We also offer same day service. Please enjoy our website as you shop today.

What’s new?

The local craft beer explosion has expanded our offering to include many local brews. Christian Moerlein, Rhinegeist, and Mt. Carmel brewing are our latest additions to our gift basket line. These local craft beers boast big flavor as well as many local and national awards. So share the great taste of our beer with loved ones who live locally or out of town. We can ship to family friends or anyone who has yet to experience our local craft beer craze.

In addition to craft beers, we also carry the famous Vinoklet wine that is produced right here in Cincinnati. Vinoklet Winery is the only working winery in Hamilton County, Ohio. Home to 11 award-wining wines, Vinoklet is proud to represent the Greater Cincinnati area in local and regional wine competitions.

For the home

Not interested in sending food, please be sure to check out the “for the home” section of our site where you will find an array of nonfood items that are perfect for any home. Items include cocktail glasses, coasters, coffee mugs and many other items. A woven cotton throw blanket depicting iconic Cincinnati scenes is the perfect gift for any Cincinnatian feeling under the weather or just as a pick me up for a loved one. The scenes include Fountain Square, Music Hall, Suspension Bridge, and Union Terminal. Games and toys are available for the younger people who have ties to Cincinnati as well. Also, don’t forget to check out our Fiona items featuring Cincinnati’s most favorite hippopotamus. She is certainly the pride of The Cincinnati Zoo and our Fiona nightlight will light the way for anyone who has been following the wonderful progress of her as she grows and delights us all.

Sports of all Sorts

Our company would not be complete without a line of products featuring our great local teams. Check out our site for products featuring The Cincinnati Reds, The Cincinnati Bengals, and of courses our new beloved FC Cincinnati. These items change often so please check back regularly.


We deliver locally and ship nationwide. Most orders are processed with same day shipping. We deliver to hotels for wedding favors, offices for corporate gifts, hospitals for those who need a little something and anywhere else we can spread Cincinnati’s good cheer.

Our warehouse store is located at 484 Northland Blvd. near tri-county. Our holiday store hours start the day after Thanksgiving: 10-6 Tuesday-Friday and 10-5 Saturday. Sunday/Monday by appointment.

We meet customers in our store 7 days a week, just call to firm up a time prior to Thanksgiving week-end.